MISTAKES CONCERNING GOD’S WILL

Chapter 9
That many people suppose
themselves to have a knowledge of God’s will, who, at the same time,
are mistaken in their supposition, is not to be doubted. History
abounds with instances of such errors. Perhaps we shall never be
wise enough in this world to know the will of God always, but we may
have understanding enough to avoid serious errors in regard to it.
Many errors have been made, and are being make, that need not be
made, and would not be made, if common sense and sound judgment were
displayed in determining what his will is. His will is always
consistent with his divine wisdom and his majestic dignity. It is,
therefore, always consistent with good common sense. The extremist
and fanatic are ever setting up false and impossible standards, and
calling them God’s will. Men of sober sense are not misled by such
errors.
We shall note a few of
the more common types of mistakes concerning God’s will. First,
people come to the conclusion that certain things are God’s will
which are contrary to, or inconsistent with, his revealed will as
expressed in the Scriptures. Nothing is ever God’s will, which is
contrary to the principles of righteousness revealed in the Bible,
nor which is inconsistent with his expression of his will as found
therein. The unchanging God does not declare one principle of truth
today and a contrary one tomorrow. God is righteous; so his will is
always righteous. Therefore, it can never be his will to do any
unrighteous thing, nor to have man do any unrighteous thing.
Men have often argued
that it was right to use almost any sort of means to accomplish a
desired and good end. It is never right to do wrong, no matter what
the purpose. Paul condemned very strongly those who said he taught
people to do evil that good might come. We are not authorized to set
aside, even temporarily, any principle of righteousness, and to act
contrary to it. Therefore, to consider anything to be God’s will
which involves setting aside the principles of righteousness, or
requires the deviation from right in any degree, is erroneous. Some
religious teachers say that it is all right to lie to others if we
have mental reservations. They also say that it is according to the
will of God that one should lie in order to promote a good end.
Speaking on this point, Paul said, “If the truth of God hath more
abounded through my lie unto his glory; why yet am I also judged as
a sinner?” (Rom. 3:7). He makes it plain that even though good
should come from his act, the condemnation of God would rest upon
him for the unrighteousness of that act. The righteous God can never
justify unrighteousness. The use of wrong methods is never
acceptable with God.
Doing anything contrary
to his Word can never be doing his will. Whatever we may suppose to
be God’s will, should be tested by his Word. If it is contrary to
his Word, or to the principles of righteousness therein revealed, it
is not according to his will and should be rejected. It matters not
how sincere people are, if they are mistaken concerning God’s will,
their sincerity will not justify them in wrong-doing. Sincerity in a
wrong never makes the wrong right---it makes the act less culpable,
but it does not make it righteous. Since God has given us his Word
as a revelation of his will, we should use it to test all things
that we suppose to be his will, rejecting all things that do not
agree with it. We should never adopt any plan, purpose, or method
that is not consistent with the revealed will of God.
Being too zealous, or
being unwisely zealous, often causes people to mistake the will of
God. There is a class of zealous persons who are continually making
themselves ridiculous, or obnoxious, with their blunders and
inexcusable errors concerning God’s will. I have seen persons who
had read in the Scriptures that “all that will live godly in Christ
Jesus shall suffer persecution.” Therefore, they sought and welcomed
persecution, and many times brought ridicule and opposition toward
themselves through their unwise conduct from people who had no
thought of opposing the true principles of righteousness or real
Christian conduct. The opposition was not opposition to real
Christian service or Christian work, but to the folly of the zealot,
who, in his zeal, had lost his senses, and no longer carefully
weighed his principles of conduct. When opposition comes to such a
person, he does not realize he is only being buffed for his faults,
but glories in it as being persecution which he bears for Christ’s
sake.
Persecution which is
really for Christ’s sake may be gloried in, but the glorying in
opposition that comes to us because of our own folly is glorying in
our own shame. How much of this there is in certain sections of the
religious world today! Such persons delight to play the martyr. They
have much to say about their persecutions. If they would behave
themselves in a way becoming to the gospel of Christ, if they would
rid themselves of their mistaken zeal, and use good common sense,
they would avoid persecution. Of course, this would leave them
nothing in which to glory. This would rob them of their inspiration
and make life tame for them. The consistent, sane Christian does not
rejoice in persecution from this stand point at all. He pities his
persecutors and prays for them. He does not rejoice that he is
persecuted, though he may rejoice that he has grace to bear with
patience the persecution when it comes, and in quietness to rest in
the will of God.
Blind zeal often causes
people to have very perverted ideas of the will of God in relation
to their conduct toward others. It makes them suppose his will to be
exactly the opposite of what it really is. Jesus told his disciples
how this blind zeal would work among the Jews. He said that the time
would come when “Whosoever killeth you will think he doeth God’s
service” (John 16:2). We see this manifested a short time later in
the murder of Stephen, recorded in the eighth chapter of Acts. We
see it characterizing Saul, in his persecution of the Christians, as
related in Acts. 9. He verily thought that he was doing God’s
service, but he was working directly contrary to God’s purpose and
will. The same disposition has been manifested in various religious
bodies down through the ages. The Roman Catholics have persecuted
millions of true Christians, and martyred tens of thousands of them.
Protestants have likewise been guilty. They have persecuted
Catholics, and even other Protestants. Today (1925) the Mohammedan
thinks it is an act of great merit to kill a Christian, and supposes
himself to be acting in complete harmony with God’s will in doing
so. No one need make such a mistake as this, for God’s character, as
he reveals it, is justice and love, and a just and living God will
have a just and loving will. Persecution can never be the outgrowth
of such a will. He who does God’s will, will be acting in harmony
with God’s character. Whatever, therefore, is contrary to God’s
character is contrary to his will.
Another common mistake
is to confuse our own ideas with God’s will. An idea may become so
fixed in the mind that it comes to have the force of truth, is
accepted and taught as truth, and is made the standard for all
Christian people, when in reality it has no foundation in the will
of God and no support in his Word. We shall note a few errors of
this sort, out of a multitude that prevail in the world. I have
received a number of letters from persons who teach Christian
communism, or the idea that Christians should have all things in
common and that there should be no private property among them. This
idea is based on the fact recorded in Acts concerning the early
Christian’s selling their property and while, perhaps, it was in
harmony with the will of God at that time under those particular
circumstances, we have no intimation that it is God’s will under
ordinary circumstances. In fact, the contrary idea prevails
throughout the New Testament. Another similar teaching is common;
namely, that it is wrong for Christians to own homes. This is taught
in the face of the fact that the early Christians owned their own
homes so far as they were able, and no word was raised in opposition
to it.
Again, there are those
who teach that we should sell all property and give it away because
the Bible, in a certain place, tells how Jesus said to one man,
“Sell that thou hast, and give.” We must use discretion in our
application of the Scriptures. A command may be perfectly proper
under certain circumstances which would be altogether out of place
under other circumstances. Jesus saw many other men to whom he gave
no such command, and he never expressed it as a general principle.
It is the utmost folly to take a command meant to fit only a certain
set of circumstances, and try to compel all, under any and all
circumstances, to apply it to their lives. There are others who will
have no photograph taken, and will allow no decorations in their
homes---no pictures, curtains, nor musical instruments. Not content
with such extremism in their own personal conduct, they try to bind
similar principles upon all other Christians, and they cannot have
confidence in these other Christians unless they subscribe to their
principles and follow them out. Such teaching is not based on any
Biblical principle. It is simply the private idea of a fanatic read
into the Scriptures and supposed to be the will of God.
A few years ago I met
some men who took the test, “Be not ye the servants of men,” and
applied it literally. They would not enter the employment of any
man, holding it to be a sin to do so. This was of course, a very
convenient doctrine for men who do not like to work. Perhaps many of
my readers will remember when certain teachers went through the
country, years ago, teaching people to kill their hogs, and to
destroy all there meat and lard, saying that it was a sin to eat
pork. Such people were quite unaware that the division of animals
into clean and unclean, from a religious standpoint, is not brought
over in the New Testament. It has no relation to Christians. Jesus
made all meat clean, Mark tells us (Mark 7:18, 19, R. V.). (Compare
also 1 Tim. 4:4-5; Rom. 14:14). There are others who go even further
than this, and teach that it is God’s will that all of us should be
vegetarians, eating no meat whatever. Others imagine it to be God’s
will that they dress in an outlandish fashion, or in some peculiar
way, or that they wear long hair and beard, refraining from shaving.
Others use a peculiar form of speech. Almost countless things of
this sort are supposed to be God’s will, when they are many times
not even consistent with common sense. It is not God’s will that
makes us extremists and fanatics if we are such, but our own ideas,
and our failure to use the intelligence God has given us.
Many times people
mistake their own desires for the will of God. They come to desire
something. That desire increases, until presently they become
convinced that it is God’s will. The stronger their desire becomes
to do a certain thing, or to have a certain thing, the more they are
convinced that it is God’s will that it be so. God’s will and our
desires may run parallel or contrariwise; so it is needful for us to
consider matters quite apart from our own desires. However, desire
is often so strong that reason is not allowed to function. To
illustrate: Sometimes persons desire to preach, or to go as
missionaries when they are utterly without qualifications for such
work, having neither the judgment nor the ability required and
perhaps being even without a settled religious experience. In fact,
this is a frequent characteristic of those who are unsettled in
their experience. On the other hand, it is sometimes the reason why
the experience is unsettled. God does not call people for such work
who have not the necessary fundamental qualifications. They may lack
many things, but they must have the background, or the
foundation---those qualities that may be developed so as to qualify
them for the work. God can add to what we already have, but unless
we have the natural foundation he will not build up and develop
other abilities.
Sometimes a person gets
the idea that he or she could do wonderful things for God if it were
not for his or her family. The author knows of at least two cases
where individuals got an idea of this sort, and being married, they
prayed God to let their companions die so that they might be free
for his work. Such a prayer is an insult to God, and reveals an
utterly wrong disposition of heart. Jesus said he came to save men’s
lives, not to destroy them. His will has not changed in this matter
since that time. I have known others who desired to be freed from
their marital relation by divorce, so that they could do something
for God. They felt that it was God’s will that such should be, when
God in his Word plainly condemns divorce, except for one cause.
Personal desire lay back of the idea of separation, and led directly
contrary to the will of God.
We may get our desires
so set on something that we want to come to pass, that we decide it
is God’s will for it thus to be. There is a test by which we can
measure our desires in order to determine whether they are merely
selfish desires or whether they are according to the will of God.
This is the test: Are we just as willing to have things some other
way, if that other way is God’s will? Are we willing to lay our
desires in God’s hand and say, “Do with this desire as thou wilt; if
thy wisdom sees a better way, do that way”? If the heart draws back,
or rebels and objects to it being some other way, and demands that
the desire be carried our, then we may rest assured that our desire
is not according to the will of God. If I am desirous of having a
thing God’s way, my desire is submitted to him, and I am willing
that his wisdom should choose how it will be. When desire points the
way and says it must be thus. It is self, not God, that is
directing. Strong desire that a thing be as we think it ought to be
is not inconsistent with God’s will, if it be submitted to him. So,
strong desire of itself is not wrong. It is wrong only when it
rebels against God, and demands its own way. When desire says, “Thy
will be done,” it may distinguish that will. If it does not
distinguish it, it will be submissive to it anyway, and instead of
being rebellious it will choose God’s way.
We often miss God’s will
by getting into a rut and doing things according to an established
custom. God works in an infinite variety of ways. He adapts his
working to the need He who takes God’s will for granted and follows
out the customs of others, is very likely to become formal, and his
worship and service will lose that individual quality which gives it
real value. Custom often becomes law and stands between the soul and
God so that it often hides God’s will from the individual. Let us
not be so bound by custom that we fail to inquire for his will. Let
us not take God’s will for granted, nor suppose that we shall find a
revelation of God’s will for us and go in his path when we are
merely stepping in the footsteps of others.
Then, too, we often take
God’s will for granted just because we were led in a certain way
before, or because some one else had been led in a certain way, or
because they followed a certain course. If God did lead us in a
certain way at on particular time, under certain circumstances, he
may lead us quite differently next time. If, instead of seeking
special guidance, we merely repeat what we have done before, we may
easily miss his will and perhaps make a serious mistake. We may
learn from our past leadings, or the leadings of others; we may take
lessons from the example of others. But none of these things will
take the place of direct leadings for today. The Holy Spirit’s
guidance will attend our feet today. His voice will sound in our
ears today, if we listen. Perhaps we shall not always have definite
leadings. We may not always be perfectly conscious of God’s will,
but we shall, nevertheless, have divine guidance if we trust him for
it. We shall return to this phase of the subject later on.
Some persons fail to
distinguish between God’s will and the impressions that come to
them. God does impress the mind, but all impressions are not from
God. Many impressions we have, come from our subconscious mind. A
thought is forcibly projected into the conscious mind. This thought
may be very impressive, but such a thought is not necessarily from
God. It may be, or again, it may not be. We must discriminate and
distinguish---not merely follow an impression because we have an
impression. God has given us a safer guide than mere impressions.
Many impressions arise from suggestions. These suggestions may come
from individuals or from things. Some may come from Satan as
temptations. Very frequently he impresses one to do something which,
when we come to examine it carefully, we see would be unwise, or
improper. In such a case, the suggestion may be a temptation to us.
When we have an impression, the first thing to determine, if
possible, is its source. If we cannot determine its source, then we
should judge the wisdom and propriety of following it, before
acting. “Men who simply act on untested impulses, even the most
benevolent, which spring directly from large Christian principles,
may be making deplorable mistakes.” Wisdom and judgment are given us
to guide us in determining what should be done. An impression is
often the dynamic which will stir reason to attention and arouse
zeal. Thus it may serve a good purpose, but we should never act
lightly and without consideration on impression.
The fanatic takes his
impressions as being the will of God, and acts without regard to
considerations or results. The wise man ponders. He takes time to
consider. He looks forward to the result of his actions. “The
difference between a fanatic, who is a fool, and an enthusiast, who
is a wise man, is that the one brings calm reason to bear and an
open-eyed consideration of circumstances all around, and the other
sees but one thing at a time and shuts his eyes like a bull in a
field and charges at that.”
As examples, some of the
impressions which actuate people and which illustrate their mistakes
are here noted. A lady of intelligence felt deeply impressed that
she should leave home and go to a city some distance away in order
to do gospel work. Believing this impression to be the will of God,
she left her home, left her children in the care of her husband, and
spent some weeks going from place to place trying to do “good” by
teaching people the gospel. She went to a number of places, but
things did not work out as she supposed they would. Later she found
that she had only followed an impression, and on which was not the
will of God. Another instance: A gentleman was awakened in the
middle of the night and strongly impressed that he should get up and
go to the house of a neighbor. He arose, dressed, and went, but when
he arrived he found no one at home. Of course, such an impression
did not come from God.
Many impressions are
from God. However, we should never act hastily, although we may
sometimes need to act without understanding why we act. As an
illustration of an impression that came from God, note the following
incident: A lady, the wife of a minister, was going to the store to
purchase a pair of boots for herself, when she felt strongly
impressed not to do so then, but to send the money to another
person. She prayed over the matter and sent the money as she felt
impressed. When the money reached the other lady, she took it and
purchased a pair of boots for herself, which she needed very much.
She wrote back to the first lady, thanked her for the money, and
told her of the use that she had made of it. Meanwhile, the first
lady had receive a present of a pair of boots from another source;
so by following her impression both she and the other lady were
supplied with the needed boots.
Another instance: A
young minister was very much in need of some money. An old lady came
to him and said, “I have fifty cents that I feel God wants me to
give to you.” The young minister took the money very reluctantly,
and went his way. Sometime later he returned to the same place and
the same lady said to him on day, “Do you remember that fifty cents
I gave you when you were here before?” “Yes,” he answered. “Well,”
she said, “that was fifty cents I had saved to buy some peaches, but
I felt impressed to give it to you instead; so I gave it so you, and
that same afternoon a man brought me more peaches than I could have
purchased for that amount of money.” Just by following her
impression, both her need and the minister’s were supplied. God will
help us to discriminate between those impressions which come from
him, the following out of which will glorify him, and those
impressions if followed out would lead to evil consequences.
Impressions are sometimes one step in the way of divine guidance. We
may rest assured that divine guidance will always be in harmony with
the Word of God.
We are not to fall into
the error of supposing that a conviction of duty or a conception of
truth is of divine origin because it is strong, but the true test of
the divine origin of either is its correspondence with the written
Word, the standard of truth and life. Impressions which are not of
divine origin may often be followed with profit, and disregarded
with serious consequences. We must carefully determine which are
wise to follow.
We note also that dreams
and visions often cause people to fall into error. Some dreams and
some visions may come from other causes and have nothing divine in
them. In fact, divinely given dreams are probably much more-rare
than people suppose. Dreams usually arise from natural causes---they
come from the functioning of certain parts of the mind while other
parts are asleep. One may also see visions with which God has
nothing to do. Optical illusions are by no means rare. People see
things in the mind, and suppose they see them with their eyes. An
instance of this appeared in the press just a few days ago: a number
of individuals declared they saw a man moving about near the top of
the Soldiers’ Monument in Indianapolis and tried to point him out to
others, when there was no man upon the monument. Visions, also, are
often seen when people are under the influence of narcotics or
anesthetics. They are also very common among Spiritualists, and
others, even unsaved people, whose mental temperament is favorable
to such manifestations. It is not so much what people dream or the
visions they see, as the interpretation they give to these dreams
and visions, which leads to errors. Many times people have dreams
and interpret them to mean certain things, or have others interpret
them for them, and they lay out a line of conduct from such
interpretations. The sequel often proves them to have been mistaken,
and their course of conduct to have been unwise. Just because a
dream is vivid does not indicate that it is from God, for often the
most striking dreams have no meaning whatever.
Divinely given dreams
and visions have some definite characteristics that need not be
mistaken. First, the message conveyed is definite. Note Peter’s
vision of the calling of the Gentiles, and Paul’s vision of the call
to Macedonia. We see by these that the visions and dreams that God
gives, whether by day or by night, are definite, having a definite
message to guide the individual in a plain path, and that the
revelation is just as plain as the revelation given with some other
method. In Peter’s case, the symbolism of his dream was explained by
the Spirit, so that its meaning was clear and unmistakable. So if
God sees fit to communicate a revelation of his will to us in this
way, it will not be left in obscurity---the interpretation will not
be far fetched. I have been asked to interpret a number of dreams
for individuals when they were of such a rambling nature, though
perhaps very striking, that it was evident God had nothing to do
with them.
God will not give us a
dream when he desires to convey a message in order to reveal his
will, or give a warning to us, or tell us something else that he
desires to get to us for our profiting, without making the dream
understandable. To do so would be contrary to God’s wisdom. We may
be assured that whatsoever God does is consistent with his wisdom;
so he will not leave us in the dark concerning the meaning of any
dream or vision that he may give us. Perhaps not more than one dream
in ten thousand has any signification; so it is unwise to trust in
dreams. If we pray God to give us a dream, we may have a dream, but
the fact that we dream then is no indication that the dream is of
God. It is unwise to trust in dreams. God can convey truth to the
mind much more readily when it is in a state of normal activity than
he can through dreams. So he generally uses the ordinary method, and
speaks to our intelligence when we are awake and in a state to
understand, to reason intelligently, and to draw rational
conclusions. Sober, sane, solid individuals give little heed to
dreams, while the enthusiast, the fanatic, and the extremist dote on
them.
To dream about some
person is never sufficient grounds upon which to judge him. In
hundreds of instances people have been condemned because some on
dreamed something about them, when there were no grounds whatever
upon which to condemn them. Serious errors have occurred by
following such unwise methods, and souls have suffered severely and
unjustly. We need something more definite than dreams upon which to
base our dealings with souls. We must know facts. There must be no
guesswork.
The way to avoid making
mistakes concerning God’s will is to live close enough to him so
that he can communicate with our souls directly. We can then have
that spiritual feeling and hold that spiritual attitude that makes
us responsive to God and gives us an understanding of spiritual
things. When we are not sure of God’s will we had better wait until
the assurance comes before acting. If action is necessary and the
will of God is not known, we may go ahead, trusting him, using our
best judgment, and relying upon him to keep us from going astray.
When we do this, he is under obligation to guard us from going
astray. Thus, we need not be always hesitating. The trusting,
obedient soul who is seeking to do God’s will, will no be permitted
to go astray, and to act contrary to his will for lack of knowledge
of what it is, for God will not be derelict concerning his duty---he
will reveal to us and make plain our path before us so far as he
sees that it is necessary. However, he guides sometimes when we do
not know that he is guiding us. The result is the same, though, and
if we avoid making those errors that are commonly made, by using our
intelligence and good judgment and by seeking earnestly to know
God’s will, we shall be able to walk securely in a safe
path.